Straight Ahead

Thoughts of a conservative, Southern Presbyterian minister who also happens to be totally blind, with comments about theology--and everything else, too, from sports and the South to politics and favorite food. Anyone can comment.

Friday, November 03, 2006

I Thought I Was Being Friendly:

Straight AheadI thought I was being friendly for all those years when I made casual conversation with people by asking the most obvious questions such as: What kind of work do you do? How many kids do you have? Where do you live? According to the new interpretation of social grace being promoted by some, these questions are not as friendly as I thought. According to these advocates of a new kind of "social political correctness," these questions should not be asked. By asking these types of questions, say some egalitarians, we are only attempting to label people more conveniently. By this cynical reckoning, we really don't care about the people, but are only interested in defining them by our own standards of snobbery so that we can feel intellectually or socially superior. As a pastor, I always ask the typical questions so that I can get to know people--whether they are church members or just casual acquaintances. After all, we are defined in many ways. We are defined in superficial ways such as our appearance, our physical handicaps or lack thereof, and our education and social background. We are also defined by our job, our family life, even by where we live. Those who detest asking the obvious questions say that these factors are not the important aspects of a person. Rather, they say, we should be interested in what a person thinks and how a person feels. We should be interested in these things, of course; but does it not say a lot about a person when we find out what they do for a living, where they come from, how they got there. Vocation should be an important consideration for any Christian. And after all, vocation is a matter of choice--at least, in the United States. None of us are appointed to our present job by a government agency! We should not be ashamed of who we are, where we work, how we got to the place we are today. They're a part of us. I don't think one occupation or vocation is intrinsically more worthy than any other; and if I don't ask the obvious questions, how will I ever know the obvious facts that are part of a person's everyday life? Maybe those who wish to be "socially politically correct" should get a life, and get real!

4 Comments:

  • At 11/04/2006 09:12:00 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

    But, alas, some of us ARE ashamed of who we are, what we do, and how we got where we are, did you ever consider that? And I think it's less than honest to imply that you do not judge people by their level of education, by their occupation and so forth. "Get a life"? Perhaps "a life" can no longer be gotten. Please think before you say things you may know nothing about.

     
  • At 11/04/2006 09:24:00 AM , Blogger Daniel Berry said...

    Opinions about people may be formed using these criteria; but that is not the purpose for most of us asking the questions. And if we're not proud of who we are or how we got there, it's nevertheless part of what defines us. It's part of our life, and we cannot escape it. So we learn from it, make the best of it, and go on. For the overwhelming majority, this is not a problem--and life can indeed be whole again.

     
  • At 11/04/2006 10:23:00 PM , Blogger The None Zone said...

    Most people who have an open mind will understand that it is not necessarily what is asked, but what is behind what is asked. It is offensive to some because of what anon said, but it is also difficult for some people to answer an open-ended query such as "Tell me about yourself." That would be the counselor tactic. I think our hospitality people at the church simply ask, "What do you like to do?" or "What are your hobbies?" Opinions are always formed and judgements are always made, but to ask nothing at all makes people think you don't care about them.And it is always better to ask than to assume. Hopefully, people will have enough self-esteem to correct any assumptions and give an honest answer, even if it is in the negative.

     
  • At 11/06/2006 10:26:00 PM , Blogger sweetmagnolia said...

    Speaking of hobbies, I once asked a young cousin of mine what his hobbies were. I was merely trying to start a conversation with him. He hung his head and said he didn't have any. Guess there are no safe questions any
    more. :-(

     

Post a Comment

<< Home